The AP caption: “Haleh Esfandiari a detained Iranian-American speaking in this image taken from TV during a TV interview at an unknown location in Iran that was aired in Iran on Monday July 16, 2007. Iranian state-run television on Monday showed footage for the first time of two of the four Iranian-Americans detained in the country, promising more images in the coming days. The video showed Haleh Esfandiari and Kian Tajbakhsh separately, located in what appeared to be residential homes, wearing civilian attire.”

The last sentence raises the question of when and where this footage was taken. No family, lawyer, or journalist has had access to Haleh in over 70 days.